free shipping at $99
The thrill of unboxing a surprise piece of jewelry each month is an unparalleled experience. A monthly jewelry subscription not only keeps your collection fresh and exciting but also introduces you to new styles you might not have discovered on your own. It's the perfect way to consistently treat yourself or a loved one to a touch of luxury without the guesswork.
However, with a growing number of services available, finding the right fit for your personal style and budget can feel overwhelming. This guide cuts through the noise to showcase the definitive list of the best monthly jewelry subscription boxes. We will dive deep into what makes each one unique, covering everything from personalized curation and metal choices to unique multi-sensory experiences that combine fragrance with fashion. To ensure your monthly picks are always on point with the current fashion landscape, check out the captivating insights on the top accessory trends for 2025.
This comprehensive roundup is designed to help you make an informed decision with ease. Each entry includes detailed overviews, pricing information, screenshots, and direct links, so you can confidently choose the service that will bring a perfect sparkle to your doorstep every month. Let's explore the top contenders.
The In Crowd Membership from Jackpot Candles offers a distinctive and immersive take on the monthly jewelry subscription box. Rather than focusing solely on jewelry, it curates a complete sensory experience that blends luxurious home fragrance, relaxing self-care, and the thrill of discovery. Each month, subscribers receive a themed set featuring a soy-based candle and a matching bath bomb, with a surprise piece of jewelry hidden inside each item. This unique approach transforms the act of receiving jewelry into an engaging and multi-layered ritual.
This subscription stands out by making the unboxing a true event. You don’t just open a box; you light a beautifully crafted candle or indulge in a fragrant bath to reveal your treasure. This model is perfect for individuals who appreciate the ambiance of high-quality home fragrance and the pampering nature of spa products as much as they love jewelry itself. The surprise element is a core part of the appeal, with the hidden jewelry valued anywhere from a modest amount up to $5,000, adding a layer of genuine excitement to every delivery.
The In Crowd Membership excels in delivering a cohesive and high-value experience. The products are proudly made in the USA, using clean-burning soy wax and artisanal wicks for a superior candle experience.
This subscription is an ideal choice for the self-care enthusiast who loves surprises. It appeals directly to those who enjoy creating a relaxing atmosphere at home and see jewelry as part of a broader lifestyle of indulgence and discovery. If the ritual of a candle-lit bath and the anticipation of a hidden treasure sound more appealing than simply choosing from a catalog, this is the perfect monthly treat.
| Feature | In Crowd Membership |
|---|---|
| Primary Focus | Experiential jewelry reveal |
| Products Included | Themed candle + matching bath bomb |
| Jewelry Surprises | Two per month (one in each item) |
| Customization | Surprise-based, limited personalization |
| Special Perk | Jewelry valued up to $5,000 |
Pros:
Cons:
Website: https://www.jackpotcandles.com/products/in-crowd-membership
For those who live and breathe the laid-back, beachy vibe, Pura Vida’s Bracelet Club is an institution. This long-running monthly jewelry subscription is hyper-focused on one thing: delivering an exclusive, curated stack of its iconic bracelets to your door every month. It’s an ideal choice for collectors and enthusiasts who specifically love layering bracelets and appreciate the brand's artisan-made aesthetic and commitment to positive causes.
What sets Pura Vida apart is its simplicity and affordability. For a very accessible price point, members receive a coordinated set of three bracelets that are not available for individual purchase on their site. This exclusivity ensures that your collection remains unique and fresh. The subscription process is straightforward, with a user-friendly account portal for managing your membership, making it easy to pause or cancel without hassle.
Pura Vida has perfected its subscription model over many years, resulting in a reliable and predictable experience. The brand has built a massive community, and the monthly reveals are often a celebrated event among followers on social media.
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Price | $14.95 per month + tax |
| Shipping | Free within the United States |
| Delivery Cadence | Renews on the 7th of the month, with delivery around the 15th |
| Product Focus | Exclusive, themed bracelet stacks (typically 3 bracelets) |
| Management | Easy self-service cancellation and management via customer account portal |
Pros:
Cons:
Website: https://www.puravidabracelets.com/pages/bracelet-club-subscription
For those who value cohesive, minimalist style, Penny + Grace delivers a curated and personalized monthly jewelry subscription experience. This service is tailored for individuals who appreciate coordinated sets, offering a complete look with pieces designed to be worn together. Subscribers can select their preferred metal tone (18k yellow gold, rose gold, or silver) and even customize their plan to include or exclude rings, ensuring each delivery aligns perfectly with their personal style.
What truly sets Penny + Grace apart is its focus on creating a complete, ready-to-wear set each month. Every delivery includes a trio of hypoallergenic, lead- and nickel-free pieces that coordinate flawlessly. The jewelry arrives in a chic vegan leather clutch, adding an extra touch of reusable luxury. This thoughtful curation eliminates the guesswork of accessorizing and makes it an excellent choice for building a versatile and stylish jewelry collection from the ground up.
Penny + Grace offers a streamlined subscription that puts customization at the forefront. The ability to choose your metal tone is a significant advantage, preventing you from receiving pieces that don't match your existing collection. For those interested in high-quality accessories, you can learn more about handmade jewelry options.
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Price | Starts at $29.99 per month + tax |
| Shipping | $5.00 within the United States; ships worldwide |
| Delivery Cadence | Ships monthly; subscribers can skip a month easily |
| Product Focus | Coordinated 3-piece set (e.g., necklace, earrings, ring/bracelet) |
| Management | Simple online portal to manage preferences, skip months, or cancel |
Pros:
Cons:
Website: https://www.pennyandgrace.com/pages/how-it-works
For those who love glamorous, on-trend styles without the high-end price tag, the Cate & Chloe VIP Box is a standout choice. This monthly jewelry subscription delivers a curated selection of fashion jewelry perfect for elevating everyday outfits or accessorizing for a special occasion. Its strength lies in its simplicity and accessibility, offering multiple tiers to fit different budgets and style needs, all while providing a delightful unboxing experience with gift-ready packaging.
What makes Cate & Chloe a compelling option is its focus on a specific aesthetic: chic and glamorous. Subscribers receive plated metal jewelry that aligns with current fashion trends, often featuring sparkling crystals and polished finishes. The service is managed through the reliable Cratejoy platform, ensuring a smooth checkout and account management process. Plus, many boxes include a small bonus gift, adding an extra layer of surprise and value to the monthly delivery.
Cate & Chloe offers a straightforward subscription model with clear pricing and value. The service is designed to feel like a personal styling treat, with each piece hand-selected to create a cohesive look. Much like the anticipation of finding jewelry inside candles, the monthly reveal is a key part of the experience.
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Price | Starter (1 piece) at $19.99/month; Full VIP (3 pieces) at $39.99/month |
| Shipping | Free within the United States |
| Delivery Cadence | Orders cut off around the 27th, with boxes shipping in batches afterward |
| Product Focus | Trendy, glamorous plated fashion jewelry; occasional bonus gifts |
| Management | Powered by Cratejoy for easy self-service checkout and account management |
Pros:
Cons:
Website: https://vip.cateandchloe.com/subscribe/gift
For those who love a personal touch and a story behind their accessories, mintMONGOOSE delivers a heartfelt and creative monthly jewelry subscription. This US-based small business curates themed jewelry sets inspired by life moments, from changing seasons to personal reflections. Each box is designed to feel like a thoughtful gift, making it an excellent option for subscribers who appreciate a narrative along with their new pieces.
What sets mintMONGOOSE apart is its combination of personalization and speed. Members can select their preferred metal tone (silver, gold, or rose gold) and choose whether or not to include earrings. The service is also known for its quick initial shipment, often sending the first box within 48 hours. This makes it a great choice for last-minute gift-givers or anyone eager to receive their first set without a long wait.
mintMONGOOSE focuses on a consistent and story-driven experience. The brand often runs promotional offers for new subscribers, making it an accessible entry point into jewelry subscriptions. Their model is built around flexibility, offering both month-to-month and discounted prepaid plans.
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Price | Starts around $29.99 per month; discounts for prepaid 3, 6, or 12-month plans |
| Shipping | Free within the United States; $10 for international shipping |
| Delivery Cadence | First box ships in ~48 hours; subsequent boxes ship mid to late month |
| Product Focus | Coordinated, themed jewelry sets with customization options (metal, earrings) |
| Management | Self-service management for plans and preferences via customer portal |
Pros:
Cons:
Website: https://monthlyjewelryclub.com/
For those who crave variety and personalization without a high price tag, GELRY offers a compelling monthly jewelry subscription focused on curated fashion pieces. This service delivers a box of three coordinating items-including necklaces, bracelets, earrings, and rings-tailored to your specific style preferences. It stands out by giving subscribers significant control over their monthly selections, making it a great fit for anyone looking to experiment with trends on a budget.
GELRY’s main appeal is its blend of affordability and customization. Unlike many competitors in its price range, it allows you to specify your ring size, indicate whether you want earrings included, and choose from various style profiles. The subscription is designed for immediate satisfaction, with the first box shipping quickly and subsequent renewals following a clear, predictable schedule. This makes it a reliable and user-friendly option for building a versatile fashion jewelry collection.
GELRY provides a straightforward and responsive service, with a presence on both its standalone site and the Cratejoy marketplace. The personalization questionnaire at sign-up is a key part of the experience, ensuring the pieces you receive are more likely to match your personal taste.
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Price | Starts at $24.90/month; drops to $15.90/box with multi-month plans |
| Shipping | US-only, with first box shipping within ~48 hours |
| Delivery Cadence | Renews on the 11th of the month, with delivery between the 16th and 30th |
| Product Focus | 3 pieces of fashion jewelry (necklaces, bracelets, earrings, rings) |
| Management | Easy skip, cancel, and account management options |
Pros:
Cons:
Website: https://www.gelrybox.com/subscribe
Instead of being a single subscription, Cratejoy is the ultimate marketplace for discovering and comparing dozens of independent jewelry boxes. This platform acts as a one-stop shop, allowing you to browse, filter, and subscribe to a wide variety of services, from well-known names like Cate & Chloe to niche, artisan-run boxes. It’s the perfect destination if you're unsure what you want or if you love the thrill of discovering new and unique options for a monthly jewelry subscription.
What makes Cratejoy stand out is its powerful search and filter capabilities, combined with buyer protections. You can sort boxes by price, shipping availability, and customer ratings, making it easy to find the perfect fit for your budget and style. The centralized checkout process is secure, and Cratejoy’s platform handles subscription management, offering a layer of reliability when trying out smaller, independent sellers. Its extensive collection makes it a go-to for gift-giving and exploring diverse subscription offerings.
Cratejoy simplifies the process of finding and managing subscriptions from multiple vendors. The platform often features site-wide promotions and coupons, providing extra value. For a broader look at what the marketplace offers, you can explore some of the best monthly subscription boxes for women, many of which are found on Cratejoy.
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Price | Varies widely by individual seller (from ~$15 to $60+ per month) |
| Shipping | Varies by seller; options for US-only and international shipping |
| Delivery Cadence | Varies by seller (monthly, bi-monthly, and quarterly options available) |
| Product Focus | Enormous variety including fine, demi-fine, fashion, and artisan jewelry |
| Management | Centralized subscription management and support via the Cratejoy account |
Pros:
Cons:
Website: https://www.cratejoy.com/
| Subscription | 🔄 Implementation Complexity | 💡 Resource Requirements | 📊 Expected Outcomes | 🎯 Ideal Use Cases | ⭐ Key Advantages |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| In Crowd Membership | Medium complexity: curated multi-product | Medium: artisan candle + jewelry care | High impact: luxury self-care + surprise | Luxury self-care & jewelry lovers | High-value hidden jewelry (up to $5,000), artisanal quality, multi-sensory experience |
| Pura Vida – Bracelet Club | Low complexity: bracelet-only monthly | Low: focused on affordable bracelets | Moderate: stylish budget-friendly stacks | Bracelet enthusiasts on a budget | Low cost, free US shipping, strong brand/community |
| Penny + Grace – Jewelry Club | Medium complexity: multi-tone, set-based | Medium: customizable metal tones | Moderate-high: cohesive, hypoallergenic sets | Style-conscious fashion jewelry buyers | Custom metal choices, US-made, cohesive sets |
| Cate & Chloe – VIP Jewelry Box | Low complexity: plated metals, 1-3 pieces | Low: fashion plated jewelry only | Moderate: trendy, glam-style jewelry | Trendy glam fashion jewelry seekers | Clear pricing tiers, free US shipping, gift-ready packaging |
| mintMONGOOSE – Monthly Jewelry Club | Medium complexity: themed sets with personalization | Medium: US-based, storytelling focus | Moderate: personalized themed jewelry | Fans of unique, story-driven jewelry | Fast shipping, themed storytelling, flexible plans |
| GELRY – Jewelry Gift Box | Medium complexity: customizable fashion sets | Medium: multi-piece customization | Moderate: budget-friendly, personalized jewelry | Budget-conscious with custom preferences | Customizable sets, multi-month discounts, good customer service |
| Cratejoy – Jewelry Marketplace | High complexity: platform hosting many vendors | High: marketplace infrastructure | Variable: broad selection, gift buying ease | Jewelry subscription discovery and gifts | Variety of brands, buyer protection, centralized management |
Navigating the diverse world of jewelry subscriptions can feel as intricate as selecting the perfect accessory for a special occasion. We've explored some of the best services available, from the thrilling multi-sensory experience offered by Jackpot Candles’ In Crowd Membership to the laid-back, stackable styles of Pura Vida's Bracelet Club. Each service presents a unique pathway to building a personalized and exciting jewelry collection. The key to finding your perfect match lies in identifying what you value most in a monthly jewelry subscription.
Your final decision should be guided by your personal style, budget, and what you hope to gain from the experience. By reflecting on the distinct features of each option, you can confidently select the subscription that will consistently deliver joy and sparkle to your doorstep.
To make the best choice, consider a few key questions. This self-assessment will help you align your preferences with the right subscription service.
Beyond the basics, think about the long-term aspects of your subscription. Pay attention to the types of materials and stones used. For instance, if you have a preference for certain types of jewels, understanding the basic factors to consider when choosing gemstones can help you evaluate whether a subscription’s typical offerings align with your taste. Additionally, review the flexibility of each plan. Can you easily skip a month or cancel your subscription if your needs change? A service with a user-friendly account management system provides peace of mind.
Ultimately, the best monthly jewelry subscription is the one that feels like a personal gift you give yourself. It should align with your aesthetic, fit your lifestyle, and add a consistent touch of delight to your routine. Whether you’re drawn to the artisan charm of marketplace finds on Cratejoy or the refined elegance of Penny + Grace, there is a subscription box ready to elevate your accessory game.
Ready to transform your monthly routine into an exciting treasure hunt? Discover the unique experience offered by Jackpot Candles, where every premium candle or bath bomb reveals a surprise piece of jewelry. Explore their collections and join the In Crowd Membership to combine the joy of beautiful home fragrances with the thrill of a sparkling reveal.
Comments will be approved before showing up.